Human ER Evolution Experiment
Experimental design Using a yeast 2-plasmid expression system,
artificial selection will be used to evolve ligand discrimination
in human ER protein.
The yeast model system requires 2 plasmids containing particular
sequences

CUP1-hER: yeast promoter fused to hER. The latest hER sequence was
given to us directly from Greene. The sequence contains the same mutation
as the original mutation present on the plasmid we received from McLachlan
The mutation is located in the hormone binding domain, and alters
the protein sequence (ala to gly).
On the original hER plasmid, ubiquitin was fused to hER sequence
to enhance stability and expression of hER in yeast. Ubiquitin has
been removed from the system to prevent selection for changes in ubiquitin
transcription or expression that could alter hER activity with E2
or DES. Without ubiquitin, it is possible that hER expression may
drop significantly I cannot measure it until I get a functional
ER plasmid into yeast.
ERE-LACZ: makes lacZ in the presence of activated ER. This construct
is used to quantify ER transcription activity.
ERE-URA3: makes ura3 gene product in presence of ligand-bound ER.
It is used for negative selection in the presence of 5-FOA.
What We Have Done
The majority of the time spent on the project has involved plasmid
reconstruction. In the original system, a multi-copy hER plasmid (with
ER fused to ubiquitin) was designed for high ER expression and used
to determine estrogenic properties of various compounds. The ERE reporter
plasmid did not provide a method for negative selection. With this
original system, I tested many candidate environmental estrogens before
settling on DES. Also, I have determined dose-response curves for
E2 and DES.
However, problems with the original plasmids made it necessary to
move the original ER and ERE sequences into new vectors (obtained
from Clarence Chan).
For hER -
Ubiquitin had to be removed so that it would not interfere with evolution
in the ER sequence.
Multiple ER plasmids within one yeast cell could mask mutant ER with
the desired phenotype.
The original plasmid appears to have undergone some recombination
or manipulations before we obtained it for example, there was
a 42 nt insertion between ubiquitin and ER.
For hERE-
Because no negative selection mechanism existed on the original plasmid,
an ERE-URA3 fusion had to be created and inserted into the reporter
plasmids.
The original ERE reporter plasmid also appears to have undergone both
recombination and manipulations before we got it. The plasmids
restriction sites did not correspond with the map we received from
the OMalley lab, and was quite a bit larger than it should have
been.
The old reporter plasmid was a multi-copy plasmid, and Clarence Chan
suggested that an integrating plasmid might work even better, so the
new ERE-lacZ and ERE-ura3 sequences needed to go into both multi-copy
and integrating plasmid types.
Plasmid Reconstruction --- hER
Much of this work has been completed. For hER, I removed ubiquitin
and attached hER sequence directly to a yeast promoter. Sequence data
from hER revealed a mutation in the hormone-binding domain that changed
the amino acid sequence of the hER protein. Two new mutations in the
hormone-binding domain arose in the course of amplifying sequence
fragments to create the recombinant CUP1-hER sequence (despite using
a proofreading DNA polymerase). Design and execution of site-directed
mutagenesis experiments using PCR were successful in correcting pre-existing
mutations. Unfortunately, two novel mutations arose (within the same
500 bp region of the HBD as the original 3 mutations.) It seems probable
that the ER sequence within the HBD may have secondary structure or
some other unknown problem that makes it particularly mutation-prone
in PCR reactions. As a consequence, the original hER plasmid (McLaclan)
was abandoned as a source of hER sequence.
Detour into Rattus norvegicus
Original hER as sequence source abandoned, enter the rat. Rat ER
was sequenced and several mutations were discovered. Two of them were
actually mistakes in the original rat ER published sequence but there
appear to be other sequence problems.
Greenes hER
At this point, we decided to ask Greene for hER clone. It is here,
and I have transformed it into bacteria and sequenced it (and found
the mutation mentioned earlier).
Plasmid Reconstruction --- hERE
All of the proposed work on the ERE reporter plasmids has been completed.
The original hERE/LACZ construct has been moved into the new reporter
plasmids. hERE and the URA3 coding sequence were fused through a beautiful
piece of recombinant PCR, and then inserted into the new reporter
plasmid. Ive sent sequencing reactions across the street to
verify insertion of hERE/URA3 and hERE/LACZ. I have inserted the negative/positive
selection sequences into both integrating and multi-copy plasmids.
What We Will Do and How Long It Will Take
hER Plasmid
Now that we have Greenes hER in hand, the next step is to attach
it to a yeast promoter and insert it into a single-copy plasmid. To
avoid creating any new mutations, my plan is the ligate the promoter
and ER fragments together, then digest the recombinant piece and ligate
it directly into the vector without amplifying it. To create the new
CUP1/hER, I will need to re-amplify the yeast promoter piece with
the appropriate restriction site engineered into it. The primers arrived
8.28, and the yeast promoter piece has been amplified. It should take
2 weeks to create the appropriate yeast promoter sequence, ligate
it to ER, ligate it into the vector, transform into bacteria, and
screen transformants. After that, I will need to send it across the
street for sequencing, but the sequencing primers are all on-hand.
It generally takes 3-5 working days to get sequence data back. Finally,
all that will be left to do is a maxi-prep on the new hER plasmid,
and then transform (both the hER and hERE plasmids) into yeast. The
yeast transformation itself only takes 1 day, but it will be about
4 days before colonies are visible. These colonies will then be tested
for function in the yeast estrogen assay. Each assay takes 3 days.
Total estimated time for ER plasmid construction (all the way into
yeast) 4 weeks.
hERE Plasmid
The yeast transformations are double transformationsboth the
ER and ERE plasmids are taken up at the same time, so no extra time
is budgeted for ERE plasmid work.
Behold the Yeast
Yeast expression assays will tell us if all of these manipulations
have been successful. It is highly probable that I will need to do
some tinkering with the system to make the experimental set-up work.
I will also need to experiment with 5-FOA and determine the correct
concentrations for negative selection. I will start out with low concentrations
of 5-FOA and then gradually increase negative selection pressure as
the experiment progresses.
Total estimated time for establishing the new plasmid system in yeast
and determining the correct 5-FOA concentrations 2 months.