CITING SOURCES AND AVOIDING PLAGIARISM
Some of you ran into some trouble
in the lectura/cultura assignment by paraphrasing too closely, failing
to attribute, or even copying sentences word for word from your articles.
You're more likely to "get caught" doing these things when you're writing
in a foreign language because the instructor notices a sharp difference
in the style and level of the language, but they are a problem in any writing
you do, and could have serious consequences if somebody notices them in
one of your other classes. Knowing how to use sources correctly is
one of your responsibilities as a member of an academic community.
Step One: How do I know the difference
between paraphrasing and plagiarism?
Read, very carefully,
the Dean
of Students' Web page about the subject.
Read and study this page carefully down to the subheading that says "Multiple
Submissions." (It's not a bad idea to read the rest, but it won't
be as relevant to this class.) This page starts out with some slightly
scary warnings about all the terrible things that might happen to you if
you get caught, but then it eases up and gives what I think are some excellent
examples of right and wrong ways to use information you read. After
you have read the Dean's page, come back here and scroll down the page
for some information on how to apply those regulations to this particular
class.
Step Two: How do I avoid
accidental plagiarism in this class?
-
For this class, you do NOT have
to put in footnotes or include the bibliographic information in parenthetical
references, because you're giving me hard copies of your sources.
You DO have to indicate which information you are taking from your articles.
Fortunately, you can do this in a pretty simple way that will, at the same
time, get you more points on the "demonstrates that articles were read
and understood" section of your grade. When you're talking about
something that is not common knowledge and is not really your own insight,
you simply tell whose idea it was as you mention it, using terms like "according
to" and "From the first article I learned that..." and "John Doe said/declared/proposed/thought"
etc. This is particularly effective if two or more of your sources
disagree on something. Do NOT fall into the trap of writing "The
festival comes to a heart-stopping, breath-taking conclusion when..." unless
you've been to that festival and you know that it is heart-stopping and
breath-taking. Otherwise, you have to say, "The festival comes to
a conclusion that Sue Author calls "heart-stopping."
Since many of you are using
Web sites, it may not be easy to find an author's name. For other
types of papers, you would have to find some way to identify the writer
or at least the publisher. For this one, if there's no author's name,
you can use the title of the article, some distinguishing feature (the
newspaper article says X, the Web site says Y, and the book excerpt insists
that it's Z), or even just label your articles with a number or letter.
-
Don't have the articles in front
of you when you write. This is going to be easier than you think,
really! Remember that the writing assignment doesn't ask you to recite
every little detail; it's a general overview. Trust yourself to digest
and re-tell the information. If you really don't feel you can do
that, then take notes IN ENGLISH and use those as you write. You
can put an occasional single word in Spanish in your notes, especially
names and technical terms, but not phrases or sentences. Basically,
you shouldn't have any sentence in your written assignment that you couldn't
reproduce without looking at the article. Some of the people who
got in trouble on assignment 1 were copying sentences that they were perfectly
capable of re-phrasing on their own. They understood what they had
read, and if they had set aside the articles, they would have given the
same information in their own words in a perfectly acceptable way.
The other advantage of doing
it that way is that then you'll have half the work for your presentation
done. In the presentation, you'll have to simplify and re-tell, because
you won't be able to remember the original text.
-
Don't quote anything you don't
entirely understand. (If there is something you can't figure out,
write me a little note and highlight it on your copies, and I'll help you
figure it out. Leave it out of your written assignment, though.)
How do I avoid the temptation to
plagiarize deliberately?
-
Maintain your perspective on how
much of your final grade each assignment is worth. Even though I'm
not giving any extensions on these projects, you're still better off taking
a zero than risking a violation of academic integrity (especially since,
if you get caught, you get a zero AND a disciplinary record.)
-
Don't use really hard articles.
If you don't understand a source, or if it's incredibly long, don't use
it. Find something else-- even change topics if you have to.
Of course, in order to have that option, you'll have to...
-
Get an early start. Try to
have your sources chosen at least a week before the assignment is due.
If you spend more time finding and selecting your sources, you'll spend
less time on the rest of the assignment.